Home / Case Studies / Generator Retaining Rings Integrity
Structural Integrity & Life Assessment 2013

Structural Integrity for Generator Retaining Rings

Generator 60 MW – PLTP Dieng

In-situ inspection, structural integrity evaluation, and life assessment of generator retaining rings to ensure safe operation under high-speed and overspeed conditions.

Generator Retaining Ring Inspection
Generator Retaining Rings — In-Situ NDT Inspection & Structural Analysis

Project Details

Project Type Structural Integrity & Life Assessment
Industry Geothermal Power Generation
Location PLTP Dieng, Central Java, Indonesia
Year 2013
Client PT Geo Dipa Energi
Plant Capacity 60 MW

Project Overview

Generator retaining rings are critical rotating components subjected to extreme centrifugal stress, shrink-fit pressure, and torsional loading. Failure of retaining rings can lead to catastrophic generator damage and significant safety risks.

This project focused on the structural integrity assessment of retaining rings for a 60 MW geothermal generator at PLTP Dieng, following concerns related to overspeed conditions exceeding 120% and recommendations from OEM inspection findings.

The work emphasized in-situ non-destructive testing (NDT) combined with analytical and finite element–based stress evaluation, avoiding unnecessary ring removal and minimizing outage risk.

The Challenge

Traditional retaining ring inspection typically requires ring removal from the rotor, which introduces significant risks and costs:

  • ⚠️
    Mechanical Damage Risk

    High risk of damage during removal and reinstallation

  • ⏱️
    Extended Outage

    Prolonged outage duration affecting plant availability

  • 🔒
    Safety Exposure

    Increased safety risks during maintenance activities

  • Maintenance Cost

    Significant maintenance and downtime costs

The generator had experienced overspeed events (>120%), raising concerns regarding shrink-fit integrity, fatigue and fretting risk, and crack initiation.

Project Objectives

  • Structural Evaluation

    Evaluate the structural integrity of retaining rings under operating conditions

  • 📡
    Defect Detection

    Detect surface and subsurface defects using in-situ NDT methods

  • 📏
    Crack Assessment

    Assess crack depth and flaw severity, if present

  • 📊
    Stress Analysis

    Analyze shrink-fit stress and torsional effects

Scope of Work

01

Review & Planning

  • Review of inspection history
  • OEM recommendations analysis
  • Inspection strategy development
02

In-Situ NDT Inspection

  • Visual Testing (VT)
  • Dye Penetrant Testing (PT)
  • Ultrasonic Testing (UT)
  • Crack depth measurement
03

Engineering Analysis

  • Analytical stress analysis
  • Finite Element Analysis (FEA)
  • Shrink-fit stress evaluation
04

Assessment & Reporting

  • Structural integrity assessment
  • Life assessment
  • Engineering recommendation

Inspection & Engineering Methodology

Visual Testing (VT)

Inspection for corrosion, pitting, fretting, arcing marks, and surface cracking. Identification of environmental exposure risks such as stress corrosion cracking.

Dye Penetrant Testing (PT)

Surface crack detection on outer ring surfaces. Method referenced to ASME Section V with acceptance criteria based on ASME Section VIII.

Crack Depth Measurement

Acoustic diffraction–based crack depth gauge for determination of flaw depth beyond surface indication and verification of defect severity.

Ultrasonic Testing (UT)

Detection of internal and subsurface flaws with axial and circumferential scanning. Referenced to ASTM A531/A531M standard.

Inspection Results & Conclusion

Generator Side: No defects detected on generator side retaining ring holes.

Turbine Side: No defects detected on turbine side retaining ring holes.

Crack Assessment: Crack depth measurements showed no crack propagation.

Ultrasonic Examination: Confirmed no internal flaws or pitting detected.

Based on combined in-situ inspection results and structural stress analysis, the retaining rings were deemed safe for continued operation. No immediate corrective action or ring replacement was required. Shrink-fit and torsional stresses were within acceptable design limits.

Structural & Stress Analysis

Shrink-Fit Stress Analysis

  • Analytical evaluation of torsional and frictional forces at operating speed
  • Assessment of fatigue initiation due to cyclic micro-slippage
  • Evaluation of interference pressure resulting from shrink-fit conditions

Finite Element Analysis (FEA)

  • Stress distribution analysis for multiple ASTM retaining ring material grades
  • Evaluation of Von Mises stress, deformation, and safety factor
  • Verification against yield strength limits
  • Results confirmed stresses within allowable limits

Project Gallery

Project Impact

Operational Value

  • Avoided unnecessary retaining ring removal
  • Reduced outage duration and maintenance risk
  • Maintained generator availability and safety
  • In-situ inspection method preserved component integrity

Strategic Value

  • Data-driven assurance of component integrity
  • Improved long-term inspection strategy
  • Cost-effective asset life management
  • Engineering basis for future maintenance planning

Why Garuda Engineering

Garuda Engineering delivers trusted rotating equipment integrity solutions through proven expertise and rigorous methodology.

  • Advanced in-situ NDT capability
  • Deep expertise in generator mechanical systems
  • Integrated analytical and finite element analysis
  • Experience across geothermal and thermal power plants
"We ensure critical rotating components operate safely—without unnecessary intervention."

Contact Us

Need assurance on the integrity of critical rotating components? Contact Garuda Engineering for a structural integrity assessment.